Magnetic Island North Queensland
  Phone 0427 398 838 Wednesday 23rd o May 2018 on Magnetic Island  
A young koala's beach adventure

December 21st 2010
Walkway “commitment” walk away

Where the walkway should be "I have committed to deliver federal funding of $4.7 m to complete the walkway from Nelly Bay to Arcadia." was what failed ALP candidate for Herbert, Tony Mooney, told Magnetic Times before the last election. But, just so we are clear on this, that's the kind of promise which is OK for the ALP to break. Not because it can’t deliver but because their Tony didn't win Herbert.

The walkway issue has topped Magnetic Island's infrastructural wish list for at least three Federal elections now and has reemerged after Mayor Les Tyrell reportedly received verbal advice from the government that because the walkway pledge wasn't delivered by a minister it doesn't count.

Labor's Senator Jan McLucas, has since clarified the walkway walk away telling Magnetic Times, “All election commitments made by the Gillard Government were announced by a senior Minister in conjunction with the candidate and went through the Charter of Budget Honesty process, unlike many of the commitments made by the Liberal Party.”
Fortunately for the government it seems our old Mayor Mooney took one for the side as McLucas adds, “Since the election, Mr Mooney has publically stated that to get the project signed off was dependent on him getting elected.”

Townsville City Councillor for Magnetic Island, Trevor Roberts told Magnetic Times, “Tony Mooney, made this promise matching the commitment offered by the LNP during the course of his campaign. Whether there was a minister standing beside Mr Mooney nodding his head or not the promise was made and I expect the Gillard Labor Government to do nothing less than deliver on that commitment.”

Jan McLucas is however unrepentant and is advising TCC to apply for some of the $800M Priority Regional Infrastructure Program for the walkway.

And while the spat between pollies is all so predictable the methods used to wriggle out of “commitments” needs more scrutiny. Tony Mooney would never have released such a “commitment” without having it vetted by the party. At least the lackluster George Colbran in the election previously stuck to meaningless generalisations, "If he is convinced the community wants it he will get behind it," said his spokesperson at the time.

How unsurprising is it then for voters to now learn that the “commitment”, which came from the ALP’s endorsed candidate, was conditional on him and not his party being elected. Cynical voters might even start to believe that they were being punished for voting the wrong way.

Of course the real punishment will be upon the poor pedestrian who votes with his or her feet to follow the walkway to lands end at Greystone Corner. The type who, full of holiday exhuberance, decides to continue legging it over the hill on the road when the bus and the concrete mixer happen to slip past each other but can’t find the room for the walker who is squished against the guard rail or flipped over the cliff.

Editorial and photo: George Hirst

To add your comment,
or read those of others, see below

Walkway “commitment” walk away
December 21st 2010
Maybe I'll have to throw the infamous blowup man overboard and hope it's mistaken for a tourist floating down below.
Now there's an idea.
December 21st 2010
14yrs ago I was responsible for the first pertition to go to council...with the help of many kind volunteers we collected a significant no. of names this was then submited to council .6mths later we still had no reply to say they had even recieved it let alone considered it! many people since have tried to no avail.surely we don't need more petitions! that road way is a health & safety hazard. I was 53yrs old when I came to our beautiful island I am now 67yrs. Come on Magi residents lets make our polies stand up and be counted. the money is there they are too busy useing it for other progects,I am sure we could all name a few. thanks for the oppertunity to respond.
December 21st 2010
Obviously, from the English, Tony Mooney made a personal commitment to get the federal funding. As he didn't get elected he is hardly in the position to do it now. The voters denied him the position of influence. Simple really.
Island View
December 21st 2010
A beautiful bit of double speak by Mooney which I must admit I didn't pick up on at the time.

"I have committed to deliver federal funding of $4.7 m ..." is of course a promise by Mooney not by the then government!!

And I thought I'd heard all of the weasle-words!
Mark Blacknell
February 7th 2011
As one of those tourists who quite enjoyed his time on Magnetic Island, I think an addition of a walkway would very much encourage visitors to filter over the hill and down into Arcadia. I went for a run one evening, and had one of the closest calls of my life at the very spot pictured above. Truck came flying around the corner and I had nowhere to go but into the railing. Terrifying.

In any event, I had a grand time on Magnetic Island, and I think it would be wonderful to make it a bit more pedestrian friendly.


Mark Blacknell
Washington, DC

What do you think? Send us your comments.

Readers comments
FROM cp_articles
[ read more ]
The poll
Should Magnetic Island commission a sculpture to celebrate the achievements of Julian Assange?
98%       2%
Great idea No thanks

Cypress created this page in 0.01 seconds